The book. The series. A contradiction?

Do any of you think they are arriving at the same conclusion?

 

because, if so, I think Epispde 4 had a serious paradox.

I don't even think this scene (http://www.fox.com/watch/448992323544/7684059648) is possible -- assuming the outcome is going to follow the books.  If any of you have read and watched, I'd be interested in your opinions.